Dallas Cowboys vs Indianapolis Colts prediction and preview: team news, form and key matchups (2026 Week 9)

Dallas Cowboys vs Indianapolis Colts prediction and preview: team news, form and key matchups (2026 Week 9)

NFL Audit · 2026 Week 9 · Game preview

Indianapolis is in a bad place, and the Colts' last game showed it. A 7–42 loss at Jacksonville is the kind of result that makes a locker room stare at the floor, and now they have to host a Dallas team that can score. The Cowboys have their own problems after a 30–33 loss to Arizona, but they are the more complete team on paper. The question for Sunday, Nov 8 is whether Indianapolis can stop the slide, or whether Dallas can do the thing good teams do and turn a bad result into a response.

How they come in

The Colts have lost 4 in a row, and the numbers explain why. They score 20.1 points per game and allow 27.8, a scoring margin of -7.7. That means the defense leaks and the offense can't cover for it. The Jacksonville game was the extreme version of both problems.

Dallas lost its last game, a single loss, and it was a shootout. The Cowboys score 27.4 points per game and allow 26.6, which gives them a scoring margin of 0.8. That is not a dominant profile. The defense is a real concern, but the offense is producing at a clearly higher level than Indianapolis. Losing 30–33 while scoring 30 is a very different kind of defeat from getting hammered 7–42.

Team news

The injury report for both teams is mostly about who was listed for Week 8. Indianapolis had Anthony Gould (concussion) and Justin Walley (knee) sidelined at Jacksonville, and both carried an expected return of Week 9. Bryce Boettcher was questionable with a groin issue for that game. Cam Taylor-Britt (groin), Micheal Clemons (toe) and Alec Pierce (heel) are all on injured reserve. Pierce's absence stands out given how thin the Colts' passing game already looks.

Dallas has its own list. Dee Winters (calf) and KaVontae Turpin (ribs) were out against Arizona with expected returns of Week 9. P.J. Locke (foot), Kenny Clark (back) and Luke Schoonmaker (groin) were all questionable for that game. Devin Moore is on injured reserve with a hip injury. George Pickens is also listed as questionable. Check the final status updates before kickoff, because several of these players could change the shape of the game.

The matchup that decides it

This one comes down to whether Indianapolis can score at all. Dallas allows 26.6 points per game, which is hardly a lockdown number. But the Colts average 20.1, and the offense has no obvious way to take advantage of a soft defense if the passing game stays this quiet.

The other side looks more comfortable for Dallas. Indianapolis allows 27.8 points per game, the weaker defensive number of the two teams, and the Cowboys have scored 30 in their most recent game. If Dallas just plays its normal offensive game, the Colts' defense has to prove it can hold up for four quarters, and its recent results say it hasn't.

So the Cowboys have the higher scoring rate and the better margin, and the Colts have home field and an obvious need to show something. That is not nothing. A team at the bottom of a losing streak can play loose. But the underlying numbers favor the visitors.

Players to watch

Start with Dak Prescott, who averages 195 passing yards per game. CeeDee Lamb adds 58 receiving yards per game, and Pickens adds 48, though Pickens carries that questionable tag. Javonte Williams gives Dallas a ground option at 56 rushing yards per game. The balance matters because it gives the Cowboys several ways to move the ball against a defense that has been leaking points.

For Indianapolis, Daniel Jones averages 144 passing yards per game, a modest number that explains much of the offensive struggle. Keenan Allen leads the receivers I'm tracking at 67 receiving yards per game, so he is the most likely target when Jones needs a reliable outlet. DJ Giddens averages 43 rushing yards per game. If the Colts can't get the run going, they will be forced to lean on that passing attack, and that is not where they want to be.

Our pick

Our pick: Dallas Cowboys. The Colts have lost 4 in a row, they have the worse scoring margin, and the 7–42 result at Jacksonville is hard to look past. Dallas has the stronger offense and a positive margin, and its latest loss came in a close game that it nearly won. The Cowboys' defense is far from perfect, and that keeps Indianapolis in the conversation, particularly at home. But Dallas has more ways to score, more consistent production across its skill players, and the better overall profile. The injury lists on both sides deserve a last check, but they don't change the basic read.

Confidence: Solid

Key numbers

TeamFormPPG forPPG against
Dallas CowboysL127.426.6
Indianapolis ColtsL420.127.8

Injury report

PlayerTeamStatusNote
Anthony GouldIndianapolis ColtsSidelinedConcussion - Out for Week 8 at Jacksonville. Expected Return - Week 9
Justin WalleyIndianapolis ColtsSidelinedKnee - Out for Week 8 at Jacksonville. Expected Return - Week 9
Cam Taylor-BrittIndianapolis ColtsI.L.I.L. - Groin
Bryce BoettcherIndianapolis ColtsQuestionableGroin - Did Not Practice on Friday. Questionable for Week 8 at Jacksonville
Micheal ClemonsIndianapolis ColtsI.L.I.L. - Toe
Alec PierceIndianapolis ColtsI.L.I.L. - Heel
P.J. LockeDallas CowboysQuestionableFoot - Questionable for Week 8 vs. Arizona
Dee WintersDallas CowboysSidelinedCalf - Out for Week 8 vs. Arizona. Expected Return - Week 9
Kenny ClarkDallas CowboysQuestionableBack - Limited Practice on Friday. Questionable for Week 8 vs. Arizona
KaVontae TurpinDallas CowboysSidelinedRibs - Out for Week 8 vs. Arizona. Expected Return - Week 9
Luke SchoonmakerDallas CowboysQuestionableGroin - Did Not Practice on Friday. Questionable for Week 8 vs. Arizona
Devin MooreDallas CowboysI.L.I.L. - Hip

Disclaimer: This article is for informational and entertainment purposes only. It is sports analytics commentary—not gambling advice, not investment advice, and not a prediction of guaranteed outcomes. We do not promote sportsbooks or wagering. Always verify statistics against official league sources.

Content is intended for a general sports audience interested in stats and trends. We do not target minors with wagering messages.

Data attribution: Stats for informational analysis only. Verify figures against official league sources.

Questions and answers

Who will win Dallas Cowboys vs Indianapolis Colts?

Our pick is Dallas Cowboys, with solid confidence. It's an opinion based on the numbers, not a guarantee.

When is Dallas Cowboys vs Indianapolis Colts?

Sunday, Nov 8, 1:00 PM ET.

How have both teams been playing?

Dallas Cowboys: 27.4 points scored and 26.6 allowed per game; lost their last game (a single loss). Indianapolis Colts: 20.1 points scored and 27.8 allowed per game; lost 4 in a row (2026 Week 9).